This is Christine and her support dog, Maddie. Christine is a Tourette Syndrome and neurodvirsity advocate featured on the TVO reality show Employable Me Canada.
On her YouTube channel, Ticking Out Loud, she talks eloquently about the lack of accommodations in the workplace: how it’s a huge barrier to finding and keeping a job and how un/underemployment has effected every aspect of her life, from health to housing.
Christine has all the qualities that make her incredibly employable–intelligent, experienced, creative, resilient, and articulate.
And yet. In an age of precarious employment, steady work has been illusive.
People with Tourette Syndrome have significantly higher rates of unemployment than the rest of the population. It’s the same if you’re dyslexic, with Statistics Canada reporting that adults with a learning disability are 2x as likely to be unemployed than those without. Ditto for autism.
Christine’s story resonated with me, so I connected with her on social media. And we’ve been communicating and sharing ideas ever since.
Then, to my utter horror, I found out that she was homeless, forced to bunk down at night in shelters, friend’s homes and rooming houses.
Unhoused. Unsettled. Unsafe.
Who are the hidden homeless?
Christine is not alone. She is one of Canada’s many “hidden homeless.”
According to Statistics Canada, the hidden homeless are people who “have no immediate prospect of permanent or stable housing.”
In 2014, about 2.3 million Canadians aged 15 and over—representing 8% of the population—reported that sometime in their lives they had to temporarily live with family, friends, in their car or somewhere else because they had nowhere else to live.
That’s 1 in 10 Canadians.
You are more likely to end up homeless if you’re a victim of childhood abuse, identify as Indigenous or disabled.
It’s my community–those people with learning disabilities–that have some of the highest rate of hidden homelessness in Canada.
“With regard to the different types of disabilities, those who reported having a mental or psychological illness (21%) or a learning disability (20%) had the highest likelihood of also reporting an experience of hidden homelessness.” (Statistics Canada)
This chart from Statistics Canada shows the link between disability and homelessness:
The Homeless Hub has also documented the link between disabilities, unemployment, poverty and homelessness. It’s simple: without steady employment, it’s hard to find and keep affordable accommodation.
These are Canadians statistics, but the link between dyslexia and homelessness has also been identified in England.
Invisible disability = lack of emergency services = discrimination
I’ve often talked about how invisible many of us in the learning disability community feel. Same for anyone with an “invisible disability” or identifying as neurodivirgent, which includes those of us with Tourette Syndrome, dyslexia and autism (just to name a few). We’re often not included in discussions that affect our lives. Nor in designing programs and services that serve our needs.
This exclusion begins in school, continues when we’re looking for work, and rears its ugly head when we most need help–and as I found out with Christine, even when we need to access emergency housing. In fact, it’s this exclusion that causes us to be more vulnerable to homelessness in the first place.
Though the risk is well documented, the needs of the homeless and disabled are yet to be addressed by emergency housing services or shelters.
Here it’s important to note that ALL homeless people suffer from invisibility and discrimination, and this is compounded if you’re from a racialized group, have a mental illness or a disability.
Chief Commissioner Renu Mandhane calls it what it is–systemic discrimination–in a new report by the Ontario Human Rights Commission:
“Systemic discrimination exists in the way we legislate and design our social assistance and housing programs, in our eligibility requirements and procedures,” said OHRC Chief Commissioner Renu Mandhane, Toronto Shelter Network’s 2018 Conference.
No safe space
Consider what your home means to you. Now consider what it means to Christine. I’m not exaggerating when I say it’s a matter of life and death. She needs a quiet, private, SAFE space to manage the physical and neurological pressures made worse by triggers, such as anxiety and hypersensitivities, and recover from simply being around any kind of stimulus.
What she needs, and what she requested of the shelter system, is simple enough:
“The accommodation I needed was a quiet space to help my hypersensitive system decompress, so I need ‘no stimulus’ in order to do that,” explains Christine. “Stimulus registers as ‘threat’ in my brain.”
But she didn’t get that.
There is no quiet space, nor a private room with a door, at most shelters. You sleep on a cot, in a crowded room full of strangers, with no walls. Christine tried to make do, and found a space that she considered adequately “safe.” But a shelter worker took it away from her, triggering a tic attack that lasted one hour. Add to that, Christine was concerned that workers were offering inappropriate interventions–treating Tourette as a mental illness (which it is not).
Exhausted, she left the shelter, for as she says “things were spiraling downwards quickly.”
That started her journey from one rooming house to another. Many aren’t clean, comfortable or safe.
It’s hard to believe that there’s no emergency accommodation or support that addresses the needs of someone with Tourette Syndrome, or any other invisible disability for that matter.
I didn’t want to believe it at first. I wanted someone to prove me wrong. So I spent many hours on the phone and computer researching and talking to government services, politician’s offices, churches, disability groups, women’s shelters, homeless help lines, you name it, but none were aware of the needs of someone with Tourette Syndrome (and worse, some were dismissive and rude).
Christine had made these calls herself. For two months.
We both stumbled upon the same unfortunate truth: There are multiple agencies, phone numbers, offices, forms and wait lists–and none of them could/would help with her immediate and very serious need for shelter. They send you off to another organization or person, who sends you off to another, and then another.
Just requesting help is exhausting, let alone finding it.
And then to be told that the wait list for affordable housing is ten years or more in Toronto (I have this is in writing if you don’t believe me).
More than one person suggested, unhelpfully, that Christine should be able to find a shared apartment for $500/month. “Like everyone else does.” Does it matter, I wonder, that most shared apartments are more than $500/month in Toronto? That this is not a viable option for many, let alone Christine? That landlords specify or imply no social assistance, no dogs, no unemployed, no disabilities? (But hey, if you’re willing to trade sex for free rent, you’re options are limitless.)
It made me cringe.
It kept me up at night.
And the more people I talked to, the worse it got.
One person at a well-known woman’s shelter told me that Christine would increase her chances of finding a shelter bed if she put Maddie into “foster care.” (Ironically, the “system” can provide a home for Maddie, but not Christine.)
Really? That’s the best you’ve got? To separate her from her support dog who is trained to reduce anxiety, and assist during panic and tic attacks?
Equally disturbing is the fact that these services will readily admit that most shelters aren’t accessible–whether it be ramp access for a wheelchair or a private space to have an anxiety attack.
So what about non-governmental agencies? There are a few charitable groups filling the housing gap for people with physical or intellectual disabilities (such as L’Arche), but precious little I could find for people with invisible disabilities.
The autism community has taken note of this gap in services, and Autism Ontario has written a call to action. Echoes of the problem that affects everyone in neurodiverse community.
If you or your child is dyslexic, autistic, has Tourette Syndrome or ADHD (all most of the above, which can happen!), take note:
Without family or friends, you’re on your own when you’re homeless.
Long story short: what’s the impact?
Based on Christine’s experience, it means you’ll have a harder time accessing and using homeless program and services. It means you can’t use the shelter system, and you’ll be forced into even more precarious housing situations or to become dependent on the kindness of friends and strangers.
It will make you unsafe. It will make you unwell. It will marginalize you. It will perpetuate the cycle of unemployment, poverty and homelessness.
My mom’s favourite saying keeps coming to mind: What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger.
Well then, if that’s true, Christine must be the strongest person in the world.
What to do?
How hard would it be to fix this problem? To be honest, the solutions seem easier to implement than actually navigating emergency housing services (so you could ask Christine to implement these changes for you; she’s up to the challenge).
To provide safe emergency housing for people with disabilities, we need:
- shelters and homeless services to meet accessibility requirements
- social services and shelter workers to get sensitivity training
- homeless strategies that address disabilities
- disability strategies that address homelessness
- more than waiting lists for affordable accommodations; help people find a place to live (what specifically are viable housing options for someone living on social assistance? can you provide transportation to and from apartment visits? etc.)
To promote employment and prevent homelessness we need to create:
- job opportunities and accessible/accommodating workplaces (and I’m very excited to see the implementation of the new federal accessibility legislation)affordable housing for all (see what Finland is doing)
- guaranteed income or equivalent
Am I missing anything? Let me know.
I’m grateful to Christine for sharing her experience with the world. She’s forced me to see something, that like many Canadians, I didn’t want to look at. Let her story be a catalyst for change.
Christine is more than capable of taking care of herself (employers take note: she’s unstoppable). She has wonderful friends who support her (I’d like to send out my love to each and every one of them). She’s finding ways to manage her situation, and I’ve no doubt she will get through this stronger than ever. She will survive despite the help of housing services, not because of them.
That said – Christine remains “unhoused.” If you think you can help Christine, particularly if you know of an affordable apartment in the Toronto area, please reach out to me (see my contact page) or to her directly on Facebook.
And finally, don’t take my word for it. Read Christine’s story in her own words: Have you tried? (Ticking out loud).
A petition is calling on the Government of Canada to ensure the that housing be barrier free, accessible and inclusive: Petition e-1768 – E-petitions.
I would add that we need accessible housing services, and more affordable housing.
- “Social invisibility is one of the largest barriers to progressive realization of the social and economic rights of street-affected people,” OHRC Chief Commissioner Renu Mandhane.